Advertisement
FTCE General Knowledge Reading
This Core Video focuses on Relevancy, Sufficiency, & Validity of Reasoning. It is part of our Free FTCE General Knowledge Reading Prep Course, which also includes realistic, full-length practice tests with video explanations for every multiple choice question.
Done watching this? Return to the course homepage to access your other free videos.
Return to Course HomepageAdvertisement
Video Transcript
Below is a full text transcript of our FTCE General Knowledge Reading video above.
1 - Relevancy, sufficiency, and validity of reasoning. So here, we are talking about the three main pillars of evaluating an argument. Any time we're reading a passage on the exam, we can't take what the author is saying for granted, or just take it as gospel. We need to look through the text and make sure that the arguments that they're presenting is supported, that it is valid. So these are the three main pillars of that. First, we want to make sure that any evidence they're providing is relevant to the claims that they've made.
We then want to make sure that the evidence they're providing is sufficient to support their claim. And then finally, we want to make sure that any evidence they put forth is actually valid. So let's break down each of these and talk a little bit about them more in detail. So when we're evaluating the validity of an argument, here we're examining whether the author provides relevant and sufficient evidence and makes logical conclusions, and this is the key part, based upon evidence. Not just their own subjective opinion.
They must be putting forth details and examples that clearly show what it is that their argument is claiming. We also should question the validity of the evidence itself. It's not enough to just assume that if something's put forth as evidence, that it's true. Certainly, we see this a lot in political spectrum these days. If you're watching Fox News or MSNBC, we have to take into account the fact that those two news stations have potentially a bias from their particular side of the political spectrum.
So we want to make sure that any evidence they put forth in a story has actual validity, that it's true that it actually happened and they're not either lying outright or perhaps framing the details in a way that makes something look a little bit different than the way it actually occurred. So making sure to understand whether a claim put forth by the author is valid, is actually true. Okay, so let's take a look at a specific example here to try to understand better how these three pillars are ... how they work and how we want to apply them when we're reading through a passage.
So here's a passage about Attila the Hun. Let's read through it here, and we'll break it down with these three pillars in mind. So, the first sentence says, "Attila the Hun was the most feared general of all time." So this is the claim that the author's putting forth. Attila Hun is one of the most feared ... Is the most feared general of all time. Obviously, with a word like "most," that should sort of set up a red flag for us because it's a little bit subjective to say whether someone is the most feared of all time, right.
There's a little bit of subjectivity involved, a hard thing to prove. But let's take a look at the evidence here and see where it falls in its ability to prove this point. Okay, so if we look at the supporting sentences that follow this claim, we want to check for these three relevancy, sufficiency, validity. So even though the passage does provide some evidence of how he extorted money from Rome here, and how he killed his own brother, it does not necessarily make him seem ruthless or feared. The first part shows him to be shrewd, a good negotiator.
Not sure that that necessarily makes him feared. And then he also kills his own brother. That makes him, perhaps, ruthless and not a good family member, but to say he's feared, tough to say because it doesn't give us a good context about whether the killing of his brother ... What affect it had on his people that he ruled, right. Did killing his brother send this message to the rest of his people that he was not to be trifled with? It's not clear from the evidence that were given here, so it's tough to say whether this actually created this idea of him being the most feared general of all time.
There is stronger evidence about Attila available that maybe is not presented in this particular passage. Now, obviously on the test, you can't be an expert about every single subject that you're reading about, but you can have a discerning eye about how much evidence is given and how compelling it seems in its support for the direct claim that you're reading, like in this case, him being the most feared general of all time. Also, just a general knowledge here, we might understand that there are many other leaders who could equally be considered the most feared general of all time.
The slide here mentions Genghis Khan, one of his contemporaries-ish in that same general time period, was also ... could be considered the most feared general of all time. So it's important here to note that it's not necessarily wrong that Attila the Hun is the most feared general of all time, but what's important is that the evidence provide for that claim. Not incredibly relevant because the pieces they give us don't necessarily directly relate to fear, so the sufficiency is also thrown off by not having enough evidence to prove this claim.
And then the validity of it, again, the kind of larger context here, there could be ... There's no one ... he's not compared to anybody else to create this claim. So we can see a direct comparison of why one might be more feared than another. So all in all, the relevancy, sufficiency, and validity here are a bit spurious. They're not quite enough to have a clear conclusion that Attila the Hun was the most feared general of all time.