Advertisement

FTCE General Knowledge Reading

This Core Video focuses on Different Approaches to the Same Theme. It is part of our Free FTCE General Knowledge Reading Prep Course, which also includes realistic, full-length practice tests with video explanations for every multiple choice question.

← Previous video Next video →

Done watching this? Return to the course homepage to access your other free videos.

Return to Course Homepage

Advertisement

Video Transcript

Below is a full text transcript of our FTCE General Knowledge Reading video above.

1 - Different approaches to the same topic or theme. So on the exam in the reading section, sometimes you will be given two different texts about the same subject, or it could be that they are fictional pieces that just have the same theme underlying them. So our job here is to try to successfully analyze and compare the two texts. And that's going to require of us a particularly careful reading of the text. It's one thing to look at one passage and understand what it means. But when we have two different passages about the same topic or theme, we have more information to bring together and to analyze the situation with.

So first thing we may be asked is about which points the author in each passage would likely agree or disagree. So here we might be trying to identify either similarities between the two passages in the way that they view the subject or theme, or differences, and maybe they have completely different approaches. Maybe we're seeing two passages about, say, the legalization of marijuana, and one is the pro and the other passage is the con. And they're providing evidence on both sides about why one way might be the way to go with that particular issue versus the other.

Or it could just be two sort of nuanced versions of looking at the same topic. So it's tough to say, but in both cases, we would want to make sure to identify both what's similar between the two positions or pieces of text, and what's different between them. The other thing that we might wanna analyze is the strategy that the author is using in making their argument or telling their story. How is the tone different? How are the passages organized differently? Just what's the general approach that the author has to framing their argument or telling their story?

And also, it's important to understand the relationship between the two passages just in a very general sense. Are they opposing? Do they complement one another? Does one go into more depth than the other? Maybe one's more broad, one's more specific. Maybe one is pro, one is con. What is that sort of overarching, big picture relationship between the two texts? So in doing so, we wanna make sure to read both passages with questions in mind to look for information that either supports or contradicts each potential answer that we might have for this framing mechanism of the two texts and how they're related.

So let's take a look here at some of the things we could be thinking about specifically when we're looking at point of view of the two different authors. First, the origins of each source. So what is the origin, or supporting evidence, or pre-existing text that the author is going forward from in writing their particular piece that we're reading? Is there any bias infused in either of the two pieces? Here, we really wanna be careful to understand how objective or subjective the texts may be. Objective is obviously dry factual, putting forth facts that can't be disputed.

Whereas subjective is there's gonna be more opinion and potentially emotion involved in the piece bidding put forward. And within that, do we see bias coming up? Maybe the fact that if we read two pieces about sexual harassment in the workplace, if we have a male and female perspective, those might be very different takes on that same issue, and some of that take may be the result of certain biases that the two genders might have about how they see that situation. Evidence used, very important. It's not enough for an argument to be made.

It needs to be supported with clear evidence. So maybe one of the texts has a lot more supporting evidence in it than the other. So we might be leaning more towards that one text, because it has more support for it. It's more authoritative in the way that it's presenting its argument. Could both authors be telling the truth just from different perspectives? This happens all the time with political issues. If we go back to the example of sexual harassment in the workplace, there, I'm sure, could be great thoughts from both genders, or both sides of the aisle on a political issue, and maybe there's just different ways of seeing a certain issue.

If we're talking about, say, a certain political issue, it could be that there is arguments to be made on both sides, and maybe the correct answer, quote unquote, is some sort of compromise between the two. Tough to say, depends on the issue. But we wanna make sure that we clearly understand where both sides are coming from, and how much truth there is in each, if there's bias or evidence, et cetera. Both authors can be used to make your conclusion, usually, on these type of questions. So we don't wanna make our choice simply based on one of the texts.

We wanna synthesize the information from both, and draw some sort of a conclusion based on all the evidence we've been given in both of these texts. Okay, let's take a look at an example here of two texts about the same situation. So this is gonna be an example where we have two very subjective accounts of the same situation. So point of view becomes very important here. So here's point of view number one, and this is coming from a police officer who sees the situation unfold. So I'll read through here what the police officer has said has happened. "When I arrived, "I saw a man crawl through a window of a home. "I instructed the man to stop. "He ignored my directions, "so I checked the door to find it locked, "so I pursued through the window. "When I got through the window, "I found the house was a mess "with items scattered all over the place "and a TV was missing. "Even though the man claimed he lived in the house, "he had no ID, so I arrested him." So there's one account of the situation, our first text.

Point of view number two comes from the homeowner. "While at the gym, I lost my wallet and keys. "Since I could not unlock my front door, "I decided to crawl through an open window "to get into my house. "I accidentally knocked over a pot upon entering, "and noticed that my house was a mess. "Someone had taken the TV. "An officer had somehow gotten into my house "and asked for my ID. "I told him I lost my wallet and I own the house. "He arrested me anyway." So two very different accounts of what seemed to be the exact same events.

So let's break these two accounts down and see if we can find validity in both, and see the different perspectives and how they commingle into hopefully some conclusion we can draw from the situation after reading through both. Okay. So first thing here, let's look at the point of view of the officer here. "When I arrived, I saw a man crawl through a window of a home." And so that's obviously coming from their perspective where they are not necessarily giving the person the benefit of the doubt. Right?

Nowhere in here does it mention in the police officer's account that the person could potentially live in that home, that there might be that reasoning for why they are crawling through the window. So that would be an example of bias. From the police officer's perspective, their job is to police the community to make sure that no one is breaking the law. So their first impulse when they see someone crawling through this window suspiciously is to assume perhaps that they are a criminal. If you look at the other side of that coin, in point of view two from the homeowner, the sentence that's highlighted here, "An officer had somehow gotten into my house." So that's now coming from the homeowner's biased perspective.

This police officer essentially came into my house unwelcomed, or uninvited. So in both cases, we're seeing the bias of the person. In this case, the homeowner, they live there. No one's supposed to come into their home unless someone has invited them in. Or if it's a police officer, they should be serving a warrant, or at least knocking on the door and asking permission to come in. But from the police officer's perspective, there's something very suspicious going on here, so they think something criminal is afoot.

The next thing to talk about here to identify is the evidence that the two sides present. So we can assess who is providing more specific evidence to support their claim. So in the police officer's account, the parts that are highlighted here in blue sort of would be the examples of evidence. So a man crawled through the window of a house, he saw that. He ignored the police officer's directions. He found the house was a mess, and there were items scattered all over, and the TV was missing, so there's really two pieces of evidence.

And no ID was found on the person. So that's why he made the arrest, right? All of this evidence supported his theory that the person crawling through the window was a criminal. From the homeowner's perspective, the evidence that they provide that they're innocent to this crime, they lost their wallet and keys, and they had knocked over a pot when they came into the house. So if I look at this, and I look for which has more evidence, it's pretty clear that the police officer's account at least provides more specific evidence for their claim that the person's breaking in than the homeowner's providing. "I lost my wallet and keys." Well, that's a very personal statement.

There's no evidence of it, right? No other person is supporting their claim. They knocked over the pot. So everything is kinda happening from their perspective that they could be telling a story, whereas the police officer is sort of observing all these different things, right? Do they have ID? No. And it's clear that the homeowner's not disputing that fact, right? Was the house a mess? Yes, both of them say that. And the police officer's providing evidence of what they saw, TV is missing, place is a mess, et cetera.

Okay, the next slide here is going to talk about the truthfulness of the account. Obviously, this takes a little bit of subjectivity on the reader's part to intuit who might be telling the truth and who might not in this case. So based on the evidence that we just looked at, certainly the homeowner's account has more of a chance of being untrue, right? It's perhaps not believable, some of the details in this story. Or it's convenient, some of the details in this story. And at worse, it seems like a huge coincidence that the homeowner is breaking into their own house after they forgot their wallet and keys and they've already been robbed, right?

That seems like a pretty big coincidence. So there is a bit of unbelievability about their account. It certainly looks bad, at very least. Where there's nothing particularly specific in the police officer's account that looks bad as far as them not telling the truth. Okay. This last slide, breaking down the different points of view with regards to the conclusions that the two of them draw from their points of view. So in the police officer's section, he says that... We can link together the conclusions between the two accounts.

Here's where we can synthesize the two accounts and find where they overlap and where they sort of agree, at least as far as motivations are concerned. So the police officer said, "He ignored my directions." And that's linking up to the fact that the homeowner's saying they knocked over a plant, so they seemed a little bit maybe frightened or hurried by the police officer barking these instructions or directions at them. We know from the police officer's account that the person had no ID. Well, that is linked up to the homeowner saying that they had lost their wallet and keys.

So at least there is some conclusion to be drawn there that yes, they lost their wallet and keys. That's why they didn't have an ID on them. We could conclude here that the homeowner had a rough day, lost items, and the robbery occurred at the same time. That is possible to conclude. If we were to sort of give the homeowner the benefit of the doubt, that would be the conclusion we could draw based on the evidence from both perspectives. So from the other perspective, though, of course, we could also say that the person's not being very truthful, the homeowner, in this case, and that the police officer was right to arrest them, and maybe they were in fact breaking in.

Okay, so if we sort of try to get a bigger picture idea here after looking at that example of the kinds of things to be thinking about or focusing on on these different approaches to the same text or theme, first thing that's most important is purpose. We want to get a broader view of a topic from more than one source. That's why we want to look at two texts on the same issue. So in the case of our example, if we just had the police officer's account, or we just had the homeowner's account, we'd have nothing to compare that to.

But the fact that we have two accounts gives us a better, clearer, more three-dimensional look at the situation to understand that there may be more than one way to interpret those particular series of events. So when we're trying to get the purpose here, some steps to think about. First, a close reading, and perhaps even rereading and annotating of each text. So you might wanna use your scraps paper as you're reading through a passage to jot down important things that you wanna take note of. We should identify, first and foremost, both of the authors' purposes.

So starting by evaluating each text as their own individual piece. And then from there, identify both of the authors' main ideas or theses. So what are they both claiming? From there, we can then try to locate the evidence that each of the authors provides to support that main idea or thesis. And now that we've analyzed the two texts individually, now we can, seeing those, what's the main idea, what's the evidence for it, we can then analyze the differences and similarities between the two accounts.

So that's where we can kinda get into synthesizing information between the two texts.

Copyright © 2009-2026 by Teachers Test Prep, Inc. All rights reserved.